The Herschel Walker Rookie and Other Vintage Cards


Herschel Walker Rookie Card Info

Herschel Walker rookie cards make for an interesting topic. Walker left the University of Georgia regarded as one of the greatest college football players of all time. Instead of going to the NFL as many expect, he joined the upstart USFL and played two years before moving over to the NFL. This created a number of cards that can be considered rookies depending how individual collectors view the USFL. In this article I’ll walk through all the relevant early Herschel Walker cards.

1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker - The Best Herschel Walker Rookie
1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker – The Best Herschel Walker Rookie

1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #74

The 1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker Rookie card #74 is Herschel Walker’s most valuable rookie card and one of the most sought-after football cards of the 1980s. Although this is a USFL card, it is considered a major release even though it wasn’t made in the same numbers as the 1984 Topps NFL football set. Aside from the USFL/NFL issues, Herschel Walker is an interesting case because he was a very good, but not great, NFL player. During his pro career he had a few 1,000 yard rushing seasons, a few Pro Bowl appearances, and even led the NFL in yards from scrimmage in 1987, but his pro accomplishments fall well short of Hall of Fame worthy.

However, his college career and accomplishments are so legendary that his pro cards are much more valuable than other running backs with comparable pro accomplishments. No matter at what level a player became famous, rookie cards for any player as well known as Herschel Walker would have value. There are some other reasons that the 1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker rookie is sought after by collectors.

Other Factors:

  • Premier USFL Set: The 1984 Topps USFL set is the first USFL set, and it was a very good one. The cards look great and the production value of them is higher than that of the 1984 Topps NFL set. This set was also produced in much smaller numbers than the Topps NFL set, which is another factor that drives the value of any significant rookies in this set.

  • Legendary College Player: To say Herschel Walker was a great college player would be an understatement. He led the Georgia Bulldogs to an NCAA National Championship as a freshman and rushed for 5,259 yards and 49 touchdowns in only three years. It’s hard to find a list of greatest college football players that doesn’t have Walker in the top 5 and not uncommon to find him first in the rankings.

  • Olympics, Reality TV, MMA, Politics: Herschel Walker didn’t leave the public eye after his legendary college and very good NFL career. He’s been a constant fixture in the media due to many different post-football endeavors. He competed as a member of the 1992 USA bobsleigh team, starred on the Celebrity Apprentice reality TV show, became an MMA fighter and announced a 2022 run for a US Senate seat in Georgia. Constantly remaining in the public eye has kept Walker in the minds of collectors.

1984 Topps USFL Set Details

The 1984 Topps USFL Football set was released as a box-set and was never available to collectors in packs. The set consisted of a132 cards and is packed with first cards for several Hall of Fame players. In addition to Herschel Walker, this set contains rookie cards for Steve Young (#52), Reggie White (#58) and Jim Kelly (#36). Some collectors prefer to consider this an extended set, but either way the first cards from this set for the Hall of Fame players are much more valuable than their first Topps NFL cards.

  • Year: 1984
  • Manufacturer: Topps
  • Cards: 132

1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker (#74) Card Details

  • Card no: #74 of 132
  • Name on Card: Herschel Walker
  • Position: Running Back
  • Team: New Jersey
  • Height: 6′ 1″
  • Weight: 222
  • College: Georgia
  • Born: 03/03/62, Wrightsville, Georgia
  • Home: Wrightsville, Georgia

Front of the card

Design: The front of the 1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker card #74 is a vertical layout and has a very patriotic feel to it. The card is printed on white and has a red and blue border around the a photo of Herschel Walker running the football. The top of the card says “Premier USFL Edition” with the USFL in a stars and stripes font. The bottom of the card has a graphic of the New Jersey Generals helmet that partially cuts into the photo. The team name, player name and position are beside it on a yellow background.

1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #74 - Front
1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #74 – Front
Verdict: Rookie Card

Buy the 1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #74 on eBay (affiliate link)


Back of the card

The back of the 1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker card #74 has a vertical playout and is very brightly colored compared to most Topps cards of this era. Most the card is pink, but it has several blue and white elements as well. The card number is in the upper left on a blue football graphic. The player name, position and team’s city are next to it at the top of the card. Just below that is the bio information which includes height, weight, college and home town. Walker’s rushing totals from college and from the 1984 season are below along with a one-line highlight. The bottom of the card has a “USeFuL Fact” about a punt that, quite frankly, isn’t very useful.

1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #74 - Back
1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #74 – Back

Rushed for 159 yards in 14-1- win at Pittsburgh, 2-22-84.

1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker rookie (#74)

Herschel Walker Rookie Card Value

The Herschel Walker 1984 Topps USFL card #74 is one of the most unique and valuable football cards of the 1980s. This chart below is from the popular card grading site, PSA. It shows auction prices for the Herschel Walker rookie card in various conditions.

1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker Rookie Auction Prices
1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker Rookie Auction Prices

Keep in mind that prices fluctuate. While PSA is a great way to find out the value of a card, we recommend going to eBay to see what cards are currently selling for on the world’s most popular auction site. Click here to view current auctions for the 1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker rookie card #74.


Other Relevant Herschel Walker Cards

The 1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker rookie card (#74) is Walker’s USFL rookie, but after two years in the USFL he moved on to the NFL. This creates a tricky situation where you have to classify his 2nd USFL card that was made in 1985 – and then his first NFL cards that came later. Here’s a look at the other Hershel Walker cards that are relevant to this discussion.

1985 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #86

The 1985 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #86 is Walker’s second and last major-issue USFL card. The USFL folded after this season and Walker moved on to the NFL. Since there is a Walker card in the previous USFL set this card isn’t considered a rookie card.

1985 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #86
1985 Topps USFL Herschel Walker #86
Verdict: Not a Rookie

Buy the 1985 Topps USFL Herschel Walker on eBay (affiliate link)


1985 Topps USFL New Jersey Generals Herschel Walker #8

The 1985 Topps USFL New Jersey Generals Herschel Walker #8 card is from a 9-card team set that had to be torn apart along perforations. This isn’t from the major-issue Topps set, but it is more rare than either of the other USFL Herschel Walker cards. It’s a card that could rise in value based on the scarcity and the great photo of a young Herschel Walker.

1985 Topps USFL New Jersey Generals Herschel Walker #8
1985 Topps USFL New Jersey Generals Herschel Walker #8
Verdict: Not a Rookie

Shop for the 1986 Topps New Jersey Generals Herschel Walker (rare) (affiliate link)


1987 Topps Herschel Walker #264

Here’s where things get tricky. The 1987 Topps Herschel Walker card #264 is the first major-issue card as an NFL player. Many collectors consider this as his rookie card and view the 1984 Topps USFL card as an extended rookie or pre-rookie card. It’s reasonable to view this as a rookie card, but it’s clearly not the Herschel Walker card that draws the most interest from collectors. All of the USFL cards are more valuable.

1987 Topps Herschel Walker #264
1987 Topps Herschel Walker #264
Verdict: Rookie Card

Shop for the 1987 Topps Herschel Walker #264 on eBay (affiliate link)


1986 Sports Illustrated Poster Stickers Test Herschel Walker #4286

In 1986 Sports Illustrated created some test cards to pilot-test the idea of making a card set based on their posters. Despite the popularity of the posters, the card set was never mass produced. However, the small number of test cards that were released are pretty valuable. The Herschel Walker card is one of the first of him in his Dallas Cowboys jersey, which leads some collectors to consider it a rookie card.

1986 Sports Illustrated Poster Stickers Test Herschel Walker #4286
1986 Sports Illustrated Poster Stickers Test Herschel Walker #4286
Verdict: Oddball Rookie Card

Shop for the 1986 Sports Illustrated Poster Stickers Test Herschel Walker on eBay (affiliate link)


1986 McDonald’s Dallas Cowboys Green Tab Herschel Walker

The 1986 McDonald’s Herschel Walker card was issued in 1986 and could be found at McDonald’s locations in and around Dallas. It was part of a 25-card set that was released over several weeks. Because this card was released in 1986, some people consider it a Herschel Walker rookie card. The card has a tab that can be scratched off as part of a game. It’s common to find these cards without the tab, however the absence of a tab lowers the value.

1986 McDonald's Dallas Cowboys Green Tab Herschel Walker
1986 McDonald’s Dallas Cowboys Green Tab Herschel Walker
Verdict: Oddball Rookie Card

Shop for the 1986 McDonald’s Dallas Cowboys Green Tab Herschel Walker on eBay (affiliate link)


Herschel Walker’s Legacy

Herschel Walker is regarded as one of the top college football players in history. He led the Georgia Bulldogs to a National Championship in 1980 and won the Heisman Trophy in 1982. In 1985 he led the USFL in rushing with 2,411 yards and also rushed for 29 touchdowns. The Dallas Cowboys, expecting the USFL might fold, drafted Herschel Walker in the 5th round of the 1985 NFL draft to secure the rights to him. He eventually joined the team and Joined Tony Dorsett in the backfield for a rare “Heisman Trophy tandem.” Walker was later part of a huge trade between the Cowboys and the Minnesota Vikings that gave Dallas several of the draft picks they used to build their early 90s dynasty.

Walker went on to have a solid NFL career. Walker finished his career with 8,228 rushing yards and 61 rushing touchdowns. He was also an accomplished receiver and he added 4,859 receiving yards along with 21 more touchdowns. Despite these impressive numbers, Walker’s NFL career never quite lived up to the expectations his production in college and the USFL set. Still, his legacy is secure because of his legendary reputation as an unstoppable for force who powered his team to a NCAA national Championship in college.

  • Won NCAA Heisman Trophy in 1982
  • Won NCAA Maxwell Award in 1982
  • Finished in top 3 of Heisman voting three times (1980, 1981, 1982)
  • Inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame in 1999
  • 2 time NFL Pro Bowl (1987, 1988)
  • 2 time NFL Longest Rush (1986, 1994)
  • 1 time NFL Yards from Scrimmage leader (1987)
  • 2 time All-Purpose Yards leader (1987, 1990)
  • 1 Kick Return TD leader (tie) (1989)

Get a Herschel Walker Rookie for Your Collection

Do you want to own a 1984 Topps USFL Herschel Walker Rookie (#74)? If so, we recommend starting your search on eBay – the world’s #1 card trading place. Even if you’re not planning to buy one just yet, it’s fun to look at all the great cards currently for sale.


Want Herschel Walker Merch?

Amazon.com is the world largest ecommerce market place. They have Herschel Walker books, memorabilia, and so much more. See what you can find today.

The links above are Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

All About Herschel Walker Rookies Infographic

Share this infographic on your site

Herschel Walker Rookie Cards Infographic
Herschel Walker Rookie Cards Infographic
<p><strong>All About Herschel Walker Rookies infographic provided by <a href="https://www.rookiesportscards.com">RookieSportsCards.com</a></strong><br /><br /><a href="https://www.rookiesportscards.com/the-herschel-walker-rookie/"><img src="https://www.rookiesportscards.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/herschel-walker-rookie-cards-infographic-2-scaled.jpg" alt="All About Herschel Walker Rookies" border="0" /></a></p>

close
Do you like rookie cards? Then let us tell you when we have posted a rookie card review.

Don't Miss New Posts!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Do you like rookie cards? Then let us tell you when we have posted a new rookie card review.

Don't Miss New Posts!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *